Overcoming Personal and Legal Challenges

Overcoming Personal and Legal Challenges

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Wills & Probate
  4.  » Why would someone contest a will?

Why would someone contest a will?

The contestation of a will is a matter that can send shockwaves through the fabric of relationships. While the death of a loved one is undoubtedly an emotionally charged time, the complexities of inheritance can sometimes start arguments among heirs.

Understanding the motives behind contesting a will is important for understanding the legal intricacies that can happen.


One reason someone might contest a will is because of ambiguities within the testamentary document. When the language used in the will is unclear or open to interpretation, it creates grounds for disagreements. In these instances, heirs may challenge the validity of the document to ensure that everyone knows the deceased’s true intentions.

Undue influence

Another issue that may lead to the contestation of a will is the exertion of undue influence. When someone thinks another party manipulated or coerced the deceased into altering their will to favor them, it becomes a breeding ground for legal disputes. The burden of proof rests on those contesting the will to establish that undue influence was a significant factor in its creation.

Testator’s mental capacity

In cases where people question the mental capacity of the testator, heirs may challenge the validity of the will. If someone can demonstrate that the deceased was not of sound mind at the time of creating the will, the entire document may be invalid. This often involves looking at medical records, witness statements and any other relevant evidence that sheds light on the mental state of the deceased.

Family resentments

The emotional landscape of family dynamics can feel complicated. When familial relationships face strains, it can lead to resentments that show up during the probate process. Some heirs may contest a will out of a sense of injustice or betrayal, fueled by longstanding family tensions.

Although 40% of Americans state that they would not get a will unless their health is in danger, many other people do have them. Contesting a will is a complex legal endeavor woven with emotional threads. Will contestation is not merely a legal process but a reflection of human relationships and the legacies left behind.